Remembering the Big Ten's 2010 bowl season
College football bowl season is a special time of year. Conference pride is on the line and fans from bitter rivalries unite, if only for a day. I remember watching Northwestern's bowl game exactly one year ago yesterday from outside Rose Bowl stadium. Ohio State fans were cheering hard for Northwestern to pick up an unexpected win for the Big Ten. Camaraderie, ho! It was a warm and fuzzy moment.
Sadly, there was nothing to cheer about for Big Ten fans yesterday. Michigan, Michigan St., Northwestern, Penn State and most notably, Wisconsin, combined for an 0-5 record in their respective bowl games. The five losses guaranteed a losing bowl season for the conference, which fell to 2-5 on the year. Only Ohio State's Sugar Bowl matchup against Arkansas remains.
Ghastly business.
So, what do we make of the strength of the Big Ten conference? Eight teams made bowl appearances- that is very impressive. Some of the weaker of the bowl-bound teams, namely Iowa and Illinois, surprised with victories against #12 Missouri and Baylor, respectively. This speaks to the competitive depth of the Big Ten. Big Ten co-champs Michigan State lost to Alabama, 49-7. Sure, everyone knew that Michigan State's 11-1 regular season record was a direct result of their mostly unimpressive schedule but there's no excuses for a 42-point loss- very poor showing. Wisconsin, another member of the co-champion triumvirate, had a solid Rose Bowl against the impressive TCU Horned Frogs. TCU batted-down a Wisconsin two-point conversation with two minutes remaining in regulation and that was the difference for the Badgers, who lost 21-19. Keep in mind that TCU was the favorite in this game and Wisconsin kept it close despite the Horned Frogs' stifling defense. The game counts as a loss for the conference, but really wasn't a bad showing.
As for everyone else, the Nittany Lions of Penn State were competitive in their Outback Bowl loss to Florida yesterday. Florida put the game away with a pick-six late in the fourth quarter. Northwestern lost a tight affair as well, fighting back in the second half before falling to Texas Tech, 45-38. Michigan also lost a laugher to Mississippi State in the Gator Bowl. Perhaps the Wolverines reached a bit beyond themselves when they accepted a bid to the traditionally respectable and competitive Gator Bowl, a New Year's Day mainstay. In any event, Rich Rodriguez's boys were drubbed.
Summary of Big Ten's 2010 bowl season
Despite five members of the conference losing bragging right to individual teams in their bowl losses yesterday, the Big Ten collective maintained it's position one of the top conferences.
Now for some fun, let's compare the Big Ten to other power conferences....
Big Ten v. Big East
Just kidding, the Big East sucks.
Big Ten v. ACC
How did Miami end up? They lost to ND in the WHAT bowl? Ouch- never heard of it. Well, the ACC actually went 4-3 in bowls this year. Not bad. But anytime your conference champ is practically irrelevant on the national landscape and doomed in their BCS game (see UConn, Big East), there is no comparison. It is a down year for the ACC, that isn't Earth-shattering news. Big Ten > ACC.
Big Ten v. Big VII/12
This one is serious. The Big 12 sent eight teams to bowl games this year and have a 3-4 record with Texas A&M's Cotton Bowl clash against LSU still to come. As previously mentioned, Iowa and Illinois thwacked Missouri and Baylor. Northwestern did lose to Texas Tech, so the head-to-head is a 2-1 win for the Big Ten. Your mid-level teams need to produce in the post-season to be top dog amongst the power conferences, and the Big 12 didn't get that production this year. #14 Oklahoma State beat on Arizona, but Kansas dropped the Pinstripe Bowl against 'Cuse at New Yankee Stadium and #18 Nebraska lost to Washington in the Holiday Bowl, also their final game as Big 12 participants. Oklahoma won a BCS game, but it came against unranked UConn (see UConn, Big East). This is an OK conference, however, I don't think there is any question that the Big Ten up-ends the Big 12 in a head-to-head comparison.
Big Ten v. SEC
Now, lets compare the Big Ten to their main detractors- the South Eastern Conference. The SEC sent ten teams to bowl games this year, including the maximum allotment of BCS participants (2- Arkansas and Auburn). So far, the SEC is 3-3 in their bowls and swept the Big Ten on New Year's Day, knocking off Michigan, Michigan State, and Penn State. However, their three losses are not pretty- Tennessee lost to UNC, Georgie lost to UCF, 10-6, and recent conference championship game participant South Carolina lost to Florida State. A lot of the Big Ten's national perception and ability to argue "top-conference-status" will hinge on an Ohio State Buckeyes victory- not just a solid performance- against Arkansas in the Sugar Bowl on Tuesday. And of course, the jury will be out on the SEC until LSU plays A&M in the Cotton Bowl, and #1 Auburn faces #2 Oregon for the national championship. Oh, and six-loss Kentucky plays Pitt next Saturday- the world awaits.
I do not await, however. I'm going to forego waiting to see how the remaining bowls play out and declare the SEC the best conference in America
by a wide margin. The SEC is murderer's row, people. Auburn alone is an incredible talent- they're being led into the national championship as favorites by their Heisman Trophy winner, Cam Newton. After Auburn, you have Arkansas, then LSU which is 10-2 and doesn't get a sniff of the BCS this year. Alabama is the 4th-best team in the conference and they murdered Sparty yesterday- that is mind-boggling. SEC takes the cake, hands down. No shame for the Big Ten though, unless we loose to Arkansas and go 0-4 against them in bowls.
Then there is shame.